Did Kyle Shanahan Make the Right OT Coin Toss Decision?

white and blue soccer ball on green grass field
Photo by Connor Coyne on Unsplash

In the high-stakes world of professional football, every decision can have a significant impact on the outcome of a game. One decision that has recently sparked debate is the coin toss call made by San Francisco 49ers head coach, Kyle Shanahan, during an overtime (OT) game. Many fans and analysts have questioned whether Shanahan made the right call, and in this article, we will analyze the situation to determine if his decision was indeed the correct one.

The Importance of the OT Coin Toss

Before delving into Shanahan’s decision, let’s first understand the significance of the OT coin toss in football. In the NFL, the team that wins the coin toss has the option to choose whether they want to receive the ball first or defer the decision to the opposing team. Winning the coin toss can provide a crucial advantage, as it allows the team to control the tempo of the game and potentially score without giving the opponent a chance to respond.

The Situation: 49ers vs. Packers

In the NFC Championship game between the San Francisco 49ers and the Green Bay Packers, the 49ers won the OT coin toss. Kyle Shanahan had to make a decision that would determine the course of the game. He had two options: either choose to receive the ball and try to score a touchdown, or defer and give the Packers the first possession.

Shanahan’s Decision

Shanahan decided to defer and give the Packers the first possession. This decision surprised many, as it went against the conventional wisdom of choosing to receive the ball. The general belief is that by receiving the ball first, a team has the opportunity to set the tone and put immediate pressure on their opponents.

Shanahan’s reasoning behind this decision was to trust his defense, which had been dominant throughout the game, to make a stop and give the 49ers a chance to win with a touchdown on their subsequent possession. He believed that by deferring, he could control the game’s momentum and put the pressure on the Packers to score a touchdown to keep the game alive.

The Outcome

Shanahan’s decision ultimately paid off. The 49ers’ defense stepped up and forced a turnover on downs, giving their offense excellent field position. They capitalized on this opportunity and scored a touchdown, securing their victory and a spot in the Super Bowl.

Was It the Right Decision?

While there is always an element of luck involved in any decision, it’s hard to argue with the outcome. Shanahan’s trust in his defense paid off, and his team was able to secure the win. By deferring, he put the pressure on the Packers to make a play, and they ultimately fell short.

It’s important to note that there is no definitive right or wrong decision in these situations. Football is a game of strategy and calculated risks. Shanahan’s decision was unconventional, but it worked in his team’s favor. Had the outcome been different, the narrative might have been different as well.

The Lesson Learned

The lesson to be learned from Shanahan’s decision is that sometimes taking a calculated risk can pay off. In high-pressure situations, it’s crucial to trust your instincts and have faith in your team’s abilities. While it may be tempting to follow the conventional path, thinking outside the box can lead to unexpected success.

In conclusion, Kyle Shanahan’s decision to defer during the OT coin toss may have been unconventional, but it ultimately proved to be the right call. By trusting his defense and putting the pressure on the Packers, Shanahan’s strategy paid off, and the 49ers secured their victory. This decision serves as a reminder that in the world of football, as in life, taking calculated risks can lead to great rewards.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here